Thursday, March 17, 2011

Fewer Nurses, Greater Patient Turnover Boost Hospital Mortality Rates

It always sounds so plausible when health care bean counters justify nursing staff levels that nurses themselves say are insufficient, or the practice of increasing patient turn-over by having shorter in-hospital stays.

Since health care is so costly, and saving money seems almost as important as saving lives, it's easy to take the justifications for lower nursing staff levels and shorter patient stays for granted.

But now, a study suggests that fewer nurses and higher patient turnover may not be good for the health of the patients, that in fact, patient mortality increases.

"We estimate that the risk of death increased by 2% for each below-target shift and 4% for each high-turnover shift to which a patient was exposed," lead author Jack Needleman, PhD, from the University of California–Los Angeles, and coauthors write in the March 17 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.

According to a Wedscape Today article reporting on this research, the study "findings emphasize the need to match nurse staffing levels with patients' needs for care." But in real life the operative question is who defines what level of staffing provides the optimal match. In many places, including Winnipeg and other Canadian centers, nurses and hospital management sometimes disagree as to what the best staffing level is.

(To access the Webscape article a free registration is required. I recommend Webscape as an invaluable source of multi-specialty health care information.)

Nurses would certainly argue, and with justification, that staff levels should be sufficiently well funded so as to minimize any risk when the staffing level falls below target due to absences caused by illness or work-related stress. Many nurses throughout North America also complain, often with justification, that their concerns are not given much weight by management.

The article noted that the highest rate of staff shortage occurred in critical care units (19.4% of all shifts), compared with general care units, where the percentage of shifts with a shortage, or "below target," was 14%. The overall percentage of below target shifts was 19.4%. 

Compounding the staffing issue is the trend in hospital care to decrease patient hospital stays as much as possible, because the shorter the stay, the less cost per patient. Sometimes it is in the patient's interest to have a shorter stay. However, the research noted a problem with the increased patient turnover associated with shorter stays.

"Patient turnover was deemed a high-risk period because of its pull on nurses' time and attention.," the article said. Admitting and discharging patients requires a nurse's time and attention above and beyond other duties on the unit.

The study approach was a "retrospective, observational analysis of data from a respected, tertiary care academic medical center gathered from 2003 through 2006, representing 43 hospital units, 197,961 patients, and 176,696 eight-hour nursing shifts."

I wonder if similar studies are undertaken by individual hospitals or, in Canada, by the regional health authorities, which may operate several hospitals within their area. For those newspapers and electronic media who still have a dedicated health beat, this research would be a good story to follow-up on for the local angle.


  1. Everyone should have the right to proper medical treatment, regardless of social standing. It's such a shame that in today's world money has severely clouded up the concept of healthcare.


  2. proper medical treatmen is very important for us.


  3. Quels sont les avantages que les chaussettes Polo offre? Contrairement à d'autres variétés, chaussettes Polo ont été conçus pour être utilisés exclusivement par les athlètes. Les fabricants ont pris en considération que ces personnes transpirent beaucoup et ont besoin d'une variété de chaussettes qui peuvent absorber la transpiration. Les chaussettes sont conçues pour laisser l'athlète sentir à l'aise, même après avoir terminé leur entraînement ou match. Oui, ils seraient effectivement paient un prix plus élevé pour le confort. Cependant, ils seraient achètent plus que juste le confort quand ils investissent leur argent dans les produits fabriqués par Polo.

    Polo Ralph Lauren est un fabricant d'un certain nombre de produits. La plupart de ces produits sont liés à des activités sportives qui sont dans la nature. Toutefois, cela ne signifie pas que les produits fabriqués par une entreprise ne peuvent pas être utilisées à des fins autres que sportives. Nombre incalculable de personnes ont été vu achat Polos garçons et manches longues polos pour une utilisation quotidienne. Cela indique que les produits de la société peuvent être utilisés pour des vêtements décontractés ainsi. Cela peut venir comme une surprise distincte pour les personnes qui pensaient que la marque Polo a été uniquement destiné aux personnes sportives. Produits de la société sont régulièrement utilisés par les personnes que l'usure de la mode. Ils ont été largement accepté comme le summum de l'usure confortable pour les sports et les personnes non-sportives de même. Il est donc pas étonnant que les produits sont bien fait, partout où ils sont commercialisés.
    polo paul shark homme

  4. I think you can make a dental appointment to avoid oral problems from worsening.
    Paul Shark polo shirt

  5. I don't thinks these are useful coupons.
    paul shark westen

  6. There are dentists who can attend to your needs. Set a dental appointment to avoid oral problems from worsening.polo paul and shark

  7. Thanks to advancements in concrete diamond hand pads polishing equipment, polishing your floors without the use of a wax or polish, is simple and afforable.